Why the lowest bid can become the most expensive decision in construction
In construction, everyone wants a competitive price. Owners have budgets, general contractors have commitments, and subcontractors are expected to deliver quality work while remaining competitive.
I understand that. I’ve spent more than 20 years in the electrical construction industry, and I know firsthand how important the numbers are.
But somewhere along the way, parts of our industry have become so focused on the price of a project that we’ve lost sight of the cost of actually completing it.
There is a difference.
And sometimes, it’s a very expensive one.
The cheapest electrical contractor on bid day isn’t necessarily the cheapest contractor when the project is finished.
In fact, sometimes they’re the most expensive.
We’ve Turned Construction Into a Commodity
Electrical construction is not a commodity.
Yet, too often, that’s exactly how it’s purchased.
Plans are distributed, bids are collected, numbers are compared, and the lowest price becomes the benchmark against which everyone else is measured.
But are we really comparing the same thing?
Does every contractor have the same understanding of the scope?
Are they accounting for the same materials, equipment, labor and schedule requirements?
Do they have the experience to execute the project?
Do they have the qualified manpower available?
Have they identified potential design conflicts or constructability concerns?
Or did they simply produce the lowest number?
A low bid is only a good bid if the contractor can actually deliver what they promised.
Unfortunately, that distinction sometimes gets overlooked until it’s too late.
The Real Cost of a Low Bid
Let’s consider a hypothetical commercial project.
A general contractor receives three electrical bids.
- Contractor A: $1,000,000
- Contractor B: $950,000
- Contractor C: $875,000
Contractor C is $125,000 below the highest bidder. That’s a substantial difference, and understandably attractive.
But what happens if that contractor underestimated the labor, missed portions of the scope, failed to account for equipment lead times or simply doesn’t have the manpower to execute the schedule?
Suddenly, the project experiences delays.
Additional supervision is required.
Other trades are impacted.
Change orders begin accumulating.
Work has to be corrected.
The general contractor spends valuable time managing problems rather than managing progress.
And the owner ultimately pays for some of those consequences, whether directly or indirectly.
That original $125,000 savings can disappear quickly.
Of course, the lowest bidder isn’t always the wrong choice. Some contractors genuinely operate more efficiently, have stronger purchasing relationships or develop better installation methods.
But those advantages need to be demonstrated, not assumed.
Price tells you what someone is willing to charge. It doesn’t necessarily tell you what the project will cost.
Change Orders: Legitimate Changes or Poor Planning?
Change orders are a necessary part of construction.
Designs evolve. Owners make changes. Unforeseen conditions arise. Scope gets added.
That’s normal.
But there is a significant difference between a legitimate change in scope and a contractor attempting to recover money from an inadequately prepared bid.
When a contractor starts a project with an unrealistic number, it creates pressure throughout the entire job.
Every ambiguity becomes an opportunity for a change order.
Every coordination issue becomes a potential dispute.
Every unexpected condition becomes a financial problem.
That is not the foundation of a healthy construction relationship.
Good contractors identify scope gaps, ask questions, review drawings carefully and communicate concerns before contracts are signed.
They don’t rely on conflict to make a project profitable.
At Tenax Electrical, we believe in transparency and accountability. Our goal is to establish clear expectations at the beginning of a project, not spend the next twelve months arguing about what was included.
Manpower Is More Than a Number on a Schedule
One of the greatest challenges facing electrical construction today is finding and retaining qualified people.
And this is where the lowest bid can become particularly dangerous.
A contractor may submit an aggressive price based on labor assumptions that look great on a spreadsheet.
But what happens when the project starts?
Do they have the electricians?
Are those electricians properly trained?
Do they have experienced foremen?
Can they maintain the manpower necessary to meet the schedule?
Can they manage multiple projects simultaneously without compromising quality or safety?
The difference between having ten people available and having ten qualified, productive people available can be enormous.
Electrical work requires skill, experience, planning and supervision.
You cannot simply throw bodies at a complicated electrical installation and expect a successful result.
Labor is not just a cost to be minimized. It is the resource responsible for delivering the project.
That’s one of the reasons we place such a strong emphasis on recruiting, apprenticeships, licensing, training and developing our people at Tenax.
We want A-Players.
Because great projects require great people.
Schedule Delays Have a Cost That Doesn’t Appear on the Electrical Bid
An electrical contractor doesn’t operate in isolation.
Our work impacts virtually every other trade on a commercial construction project.
Underground utilities, temporary power, rough-in, electrical rooms, equipment connections, lighting, life safety systems, inspections and commissioning all play important roles in the overall schedule.
When electrical work falls behind, the consequences can extend far beyond the electrical subcontract.
Ceilings can’t close.
Equipment can’t start.
Inspections get delayed.
Other trades are forced to reschedule.
Occupancy dates become uncertain.
And the general contractor is left managing the consequences.
A contractor who saves $50,000 on bid day but contributes to weeks of avoidable delays may not have saved the project anything.
That’s why scheduling, coordination and manpower planning should be part of evaluating an electrical contractor, not simply discussions that occur after the contract has been awarded.
Rework Is One of the Most Expensive Things in Construction
There is an old saying in construction:
If you don’t have time to do it right the first time, when will you have time to do it over?
Rework is expensive.
It consumes labor, materials, supervision and schedule.
It creates frustration between trades and can damage relationships with owners and general contractors.
And in electrical construction, poor workmanship can create consequences that extend well beyond the completion of a project.
This is why quality control matters.
This is why training matters.
This is why experienced supervision matters.
And this is why safety and professionalism should never be treated as optional expenses that can be eliminated to make a bid more competitive.
Doing it right the first time isn’t expensive. Doing it twice is.
The Best Contractors Don’t Just Install. They Solve Problems.
I believe the best electrical contractors bring far more value to a project than the labor and materials included in their proposal.
They help identify design challenges.
They offer practical value engineering solutions.
They coordinate with other trades.
They anticipate procurement concerns.
They communicate schedule risks.
They take ownership of their responsibilities.
And when problems arise, they come to the table with solutions rather than excuses.
That kind of partnership has tremendous value.
It may not always be reflected in the initial bid comparison, but it becomes very apparent during construction.
A great subcontractor makes a general contractor’s job easier.
A poor subcontractor can make an otherwise successful project miserable.
General Contractors Shouldn’t Have to Babysit Their Subcontractors
This is something I feel strongly about.
General contractors already have enough responsibilities.
They are coordinating dozens of moving parts, managing owners, maintaining schedules, monitoring budgets and overseeing safety and quality.
The last thing they need is an electrical contractor who requires constant supervision just to perform the work they were hired to do.
A professional electrical contractor should be able to manage its people, coordinate its scope, communicate proactively and execute its responsibilities.
That doesn’t mean there won’t be challenges.
Construction is complicated. There will always be challenges.
But there is a big difference between a subcontractor who helps solve those challenges and one who consistently creates them.
The right trade partner should reduce the general contractor’s workload, not increase it.
At Tenax, We Don’t Want to Be the Cheapest. We Want to Be the Right Choice.
We are building Tenax Electrical around a straightforward philosophy.
Safety.
Respect.
Professionalism.
We believe in investing in our people, building strong relationships, communicating transparently and delivering the kind of experience our customers and construction partners deserve.
We believe in doing what we say we’re going to do.
We believe in taking ownership.
And we believe that our reputation is worth more than any individual project.
Does that mean we’ll always be the lowest bidder?
No.
Does it mean we won’t be competitive?
Absolutely not.
We understand that pricing matters. We work hard to be competitive, efficient and responsible with our customers’ money.
But we are not interested in winning projects at numbers that compromise our ability to deliver the level of service, quality and professionalism our partners expect.
That’s not good for Tenax.
And it’s certainly not good for our customers.
The Bottom Line: Buy Value, Not Just Price
My message to owners, developers and general contractors is simple.
Keep bidding competitively.
Keep holding contractors accountable.
Keep demanding fair pricing.
But look beyond the number at the bottom of the proposal.
Ask about experience.
Ask about manpower.
Ask about supervision.
Ask about safety.
Ask about quality control.
Ask about procurement and scheduling.
Ask how the contractor handles challenges when things don’t go according to plan.
And perhaps most importantly, ask yourself whether this is a company you trust to be part of your team.
Because at the end of the day, the success of a construction project isn’t measured by how much money was saved on bid day. It’s measured by the quality, cost and timeliness of the completed project.
The cheapest electrical contractor isn’t always the wrong choice.
But the lowest price and the best value are two very different things.
And understanding that difference before awarding a contract can save everyone a tremendous amount of money, time and frustration.
Hire the contractor who will help make your project successful, not simply the one who makes your bid tab look better.
David Yencarelli
President | Tenax Electrical Company
Jacksonville, Florida
Tenax Electrical Company provides commercial, industrial and residential electrical construction, service and maintenance throughout Northeast Florida.
Respect for Every Connection.
